Does having too many pickups affect guitar tone, or sustain? Let's suppose a guitar has eight pickups while another one has just one of the same type. Would there be a tone difference, if the mega-pickup one was only using one of its pickups in a similar position to the single pickup guitar? Or would the effect of the extra pickups be too small to notice?
is there such a thing as too many pickups?
7 Comments
Crisps@lemmy.world · 18 pts · 2y
Is this what they call a pickup line?
stephenc@waveform.social · 5 pts · 2y
That's some magnetic personality you've got.
raindrop1988@lemmy.world · 13 pts · 2y
Well people do say that the magnetic attraction that the pickups have on the strings can reduce sustain. Ergo, more pickups = less sustain. Whether that effect would be noticeable is debatable.
I have to say my first response to the pic was: “how much hum would a humbucker buck if a humbucker could buck hum?”.
Edit: a word
ReaderTunesOctopus@lemmy.world · 4 pts · 2y
A humbucker would hum as much as a humbucker could hum if a humbucker could buck hum, I guess
TokyoMonsterTrucker@lemmy.dbzer0.com · 4 pts · 2y
When I bought my tele the pickups were way too high. The stronger magnetic field killed the sustain on thickers strings and actually affected the frequency produced on the higher frets. I would assume that a wall of pickups would have a similar negative effects.
PinkOwls@feddit.de · 2 pts · 2y
So, a pickup creates a magnetic pull on the strings, and this does have an effect on the way the strings are vibrating. It's an experiment you can do yourself: You can adjust the height of the pickup so that it gets closer to the strings. If it's close enough, you will hear a vibrato-effect when you're playing. Well, that's undesirable, unless you want to have vibrato everywhere.
So, if there's more magnetic pull on the strings, there's a higher possibility for unwanted vibrato; this could mean that you need to adjust the height, so that the pickups are lower (further away from the strings). Lower means a weaker signal/output; and the different strings might be affected differently, so this means different tone overall.
pr06lefs@lemmy.ml · 4 pts · 2y
I have a guitar with a truckload of pickups. But I've never detected any vibrato - where the pitch oscillates up and down. Maybe this effect is not noticeable if the pickups are at a typical distance from the strings.