Hooray…still thinking about how apparently the OpenAI and Anthropic PR teams were impressed with this doc, which is a pretty clear indicator of what it’s going to be like
the reviews on imdb have dropped a bit (from 8.5 down to 7.5) but that’ll probably change when the full thing drops
Also is it just me or does the trailer have a weirdly large views vs likes ratio? 5.6mil views with only 6.7K likes? is that the norm for documentaries?
With my extremely scientific method of "clicking on trailers for random documentaries and seeing the ratios" the like-to-view ratio is typically in a range from 1-10 to 1-100. The biggest outlier I saw was probably Will & Harper at about 1-400. The AI Doc is about 1-800.
Also interesting is the comments. Will & Harper has about 6400 comments while the AI Doc only has 640, which would be comparable to something like Murder in Monaco, a documentary trailer with about a tenth of the views (and also has a comparable amount of likes).
That dot on the top right is the AI doc.
The dot on the bottom right is UNKNOWN: Killer Robots
The dot on the top is American Symphony
In both of those instances they're comparable on one axis but not the other.
So basically if this chart's correct there's definitely cause for suspicion. Moreso anyway.
Edit: I made a typo in the data, which gave UNKNOWN: Killer Robots and UNKNOWN: Cosmic Time Machine a higher View Per Like ratio than it should have.
Here's the new chart:
The other guy is probably right that its a case of AI fanatics using chatbots to summarise what its about without actually engaging with it in any meaningful way (liking and commenting)
Also is it just me or does the trailer have a weirdly large views vs likes ratio? 5.6mil views with only 6.7K likes? is that the norm for documentaries?
Most of the views are probably the target demographic feeding it to a chatbot to summarize without ever opening the page in a real browser.
They're going to have their AI watch it and summarize it for them so then can nod their head and go "mmhm" and know that they are truly the pioneers of the Future...
Well this is out now, and I'm surprised to announce the ratings went down from 7.5 from 7.1 on imdb and only 60/100 on Metacritic, though there are only 9 critic reviews and 5 user reviews, which itself is surprising for being so little. Rotten Tomatoes is higher, but only 38 critic reviews and over 50 ratings. I'm surprised it seems to be so unpopular, I thought it'd be blowing up with hundreds of ratings
14 Comments
lurker@awful.systems · 10 pts · 182d
Hooray…still thinking about how apparently the OpenAI and Anthropic PR teams were impressed with this doc, which is a pretty clear indicator of what it’s going to be like
the reviews on imdb have dropped a bit (from 8.5 down to 7.5) but that’ll probably change when the full thing drops
Also is it just me or does the trailer have a weirdly large views vs likes ratio? 5.6mil views with only 6.7K likes? is that the norm for documentaries?
ShakingMyHead@awful.systems · 5 pts · 180d
With my extremely scientific method of "clicking on trailers for random documentaries and seeing the ratios" the like-to-view ratio is typically in a range from 1-10 to 1-100. The biggest outlier I saw was probably Will & Harper at about 1-400. The AI Doc is about 1-800. Also interesting is the comments. Will & Harper has about 6400 comments while the AI Doc only has 640, which would be comparable to something like Murder in Monaco, a documentary trailer with about a tenth of the views (and also has a comparable amount of likes).
lurker@awful.systems · 3 pts · 179d
Thank you for your rigorous scientific studying stranger
ShakingMyHead@awful.systems · 5 pts · 179d
Sorry if this is unsolicited, but I decided to put a bit more rigour into it and check the average of 100 netflix documentary trailers from here
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLvahqwMqN4M0fmh2gjEqNbUA3uCVMZbDB
And make a chart.
That dot on the top right is the AI doc.
The dot on the bottom right is UNKNOWN: Killer Robots
The dot on the top is American Symphony
In both of those instances they're comparable on one axis but not the other.
So basically if this chart's correct there's definitely cause for suspicion. Moreso anyway.
Edit: I made a typo in the data, which gave UNKNOWN: Killer Robots and UNKNOWN: Cosmic Time Machine a higher View Per Like ratio than it should have. Here's the new chart:
The new Furthest right are now
American Nightmare
and
Will & Harper
lurker@awful.systems · 3 pts · 179d
Damn, that is way, way bigger than I thought
The other guy is probably right that its a case of AI fanatics using chatbots to summarise what its about without actually engaging with it in any meaningful way (liking and commenting)
Architeuthis@awful.systems · 3 pts · 180d
Most of the views are probably the target demographic feeding it to a chatbot to summarize without ever opening the page in a real browser.
lurker@awful.systems · 2 pts · 179d
well thats fucking depressing to think about. You're probably right tho
blakestacey@awful.systems · 7 pts · 182d
Who the balls is the market for an AI-glazing "documentary"? The more one likes the technology, the shorter one's attention span.
arbitraryidentifier@awful.systems · 6 pts · 181d
They're going to have their AI watch it and summarize it for them so then can nod their head and go "mmhm" and know that they are truly the pioneers of the Future...
istewart@awful.systems · 2 pts · 180d
"Look, Grandpa, here's what we should invest the trust fund into!"
Architeuthis@awful.systems · 5 pts · 182d
Obligatory link to the previous thread
BurgersMcSlopshot@awful.systems · 5 pts · 182d
What the fuck is this, Pets Dot Com, the musical?
lurker@awful.systems · 2 pts · 172d
Well this is out now, and I'm surprised to announce the ratings went down from 7.5 from 7.1 on imdb and only 60/100 on Metacritic, though there are only 9 critic reviews and 5 user reviews, which itself is surprising for being so little. Rotten Tomatoes is higher, but only 38 critic reviews and over 50 ratings. I'm surprised it seems to be so unpopular, I thought it'd be blowing up with hundreds of ratings
dgerard@awful.systems · 1 pts · 169d
yeah this is the bad one. The good one is Ghost In The Machine.