i like a lot of anarchism, it was the first political ideology i really identified with. this is the thing that turned me off of it - both the casting of a certain group of people (people who i have known) as unworthy of society and the ever-frustrating lie that someone must be left behind. i would be thrilled if anarchism had a solution not motivated or executed cruelly. i have not found one in anarchism, and i don't think it's disingenuous for me ask you for one or to say that i find your acceptance callous.
i do not have any big ideas for the justice system of your anarchist society, i'm not the anarchist. i don't have anarchist solutions. being 'open to alternatives' isn't particularly comforting given that you seem perfectly willing to default back to ritual murder by exile if you don't find something you like. i'm not interested in a society that has a built-in death toll for a particular group of people.
i like a lot of anarchism, it was the first political ideology i really identified with. this is the thing that turned me off of it - both the casting of a certain group of people (people who i have known) as unworthy of society and the ever-frustrating lie that someone must be left behind. i would be thrilled if anarchism had a solution not motivated or executed cruelly. i have not found one in anarchism, and i don't think it's disingenuous for me ask you for one or to say that i find your acceptance callous.
i do not have any big ideas for the justice system of your anarchist society, i'm not the anarchist. i don't have anarchist solutions. being 'open to alternatives' isn't particularly comforting given that you seem perfectly willing to default back to ritual murder by exile if you don't find something you like. i'm not interested in a society that has a built-in death toll for a particular group of people.
your ideal society has a mechanism for depersoning a certain group of people to the point that they can be sent to die in the wilderness?
what about the people you expell? what happens to them?