Only downside is the MIT license, but they are doing good work. Glad they started the project. It also makes it easier to integrate onto other operating systems thanks to the rust toolchain.
Pedants will be quick to point out that the original sudo is also pushover licensed, but that doesn't change the fact that this is still a downside in the Rust version as well.
Iām a big fan of gpl everything, but when sudo was getting installed in everything the argument that āthis great security technology needs to be permissively licensed so there will be no reason for companies to not make its use standard practiceā held a lot of weight!
Theyāre absolutely right about the packaging for many distros needing work - Iāve been using sudo-rs as a replacement for sudo on arch for a long time now and itās been great, except for the install. Installing this and removing the original sudo was a pain in the ass and requires installing the original sudo first to get the default configs. If this changed, I think a lot more people would try it and adoption would benefit a lot.
My only problem with sudo-rs is that unlike the other rust rewrites. Compatibility isn't a goal. I use the -E flag for some very specific programs and trying to manually pass in a bunch of different variables from my user environment has proven both tedious and in some cases doing so still results in programs not launching as I don't know exactly which variable it needs.
7 Comments
onlinepersona@programming.dev · 6 pts · 98d
Only downside is the MIT license, but they are doing good work. Glad they started the project. It also makes it easier to integrate onto other operating systems thanks to the rust toolchain.
trevor@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 4 pts · 98d
Pedants will be quick to point out that the original sudo is also pushover licensed, but that doesn't change the fact that this is still a downside in the Rust version as well.
db2@lemmy.world · 5 pts · 98d
What happened in 1997 š¤
nyan@sh.itjust.works · 6 pts · 98d
We don't talk about 1997. It might hear. š±
doodoo_wizard@lemmy.ml · 3 pts · 97d
Iām a big fan of gpl everything, but when sudo was getting installed in everything the argument that āthis great security technology needs to be permissively licensed so there will be no reason for companies to not make its use standard practiceā held a lot of weight!
felsiq@piefed.zip · 5 pts · 98d
Theyāre absolutely right about the packaging for many distros needing work - Iāve been using sudo-rs as a replacement for sudo on arch for a long time now and itās been great, except for the install. Installing this and removing the original sudo was a pain in the ass and requires installing the original sudo first to get the default configs. If this changed, I think a lot more people would try it and adoption would benefit a lot.
D_Air1@lemmy.ml · 2 pts · 97d
My only problem with sudo-rs is that unlike the other rust rewrites. Compatibility isn't a goal. I use the
-Eflag for some very specific programs and trying to manually pass in a bunch of different variables from my user environment has proven both tedious and in some cases doing so still results in programs not launching as I don't know exactly which variable it needs.