Why Horizontal Scrolling Never Caught On - Interface Studies

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5XphZYVBH3Y

They go over how the web and frameworks decided against horizontal, apart from deliberate emphasis, they go over some desktop layout attempts, failures and successes (more of the same vs navigation), a chapter about (paper) documents as the source, and endless panes now using horizontal.

From the description:

Almost every screen we use is a landscape rectangle, wider than it is tall. And on almost all of them, the content moves vertically. Always down.

This video walks through a wrong question. If mobile scrolls down, why doesn't the desktop scroll sideways?

The question turns out to be wrong.

Chapters

  • [00:00] Introduction
  • [01:23] The Web Could, and Doesn't
  • [03:18] The Microsoft Bet - Windows 8 "Metro"/"Modern" failure
  • [06:18] What Makes a Difference - Layouts where horizontal works
  • [09:14] Horizontal Scrolling as Emphasis
  • [10:24] When Horizontal Axis Means Something
  • [12:13] The Document Model
  • [14:06] The Potential of a Glass Plane

References

6 points · 6 comments · view on lemmy.world

6 Comments

schwim@piefed.zip · 14 pts · 35d (2 replies)

Mousewheel. End of study.

valar@lemmy.ca · 3 pts · 34d (1 reply)

This would be my guess. Fingers can wiggle up and down easier than side to side. /shrug

iocase@lemmy.zip · 3 pts · 34d

It's also how we're trained for thousands of hours to read text. Left to right, then progress top to bottom. That makes more intuitive sense to more people than scrolling endlessly to the right.

AwesomeLowlander@sh.itjust.works · 6 pts · 34d (2 replies)

Tldw? (Any video is Tldw)

chicken@lemmy.dbzer0.com · 4 pts · 34d

the web is not vertical because the spec demands it, the web is vertical because the people who design websites the people who write the frameworks and the people who teach usability all agreed implicitly and over 20 years that sideways was a layout failure

Kissaki@programming.dev · 2 pts · 34d

I forgot to add the description and chapters. I added them now.

They go over how the web and frameworks decided against horizontal, apart from deliberate emphasis, they go over some desktop layout attempts, failures and successes (more of the same vs navigation), a chapter about (paper) documents as the source, and endless panes now using horizontal.