You’ve said plenty pro-AI lol. You don’t have to get so defensive about it, just own your position.
I’ve exaggerated nothing. Hank himself said he’s spoken to both his wife and brother about his AI use and said they “didn’t pull any punches”, which implies there was a blunt conversation about it, if not two.
Startup doesn’t really have a strict definition but generally the term is used for a business with an unproven business model that has to scale rapidly just to be viable, and often relies on VC funding. This is opposed to like starting your own plumbing business with your own capital and you’re profitable as soon as you pick up a couple regular clients.
OpenAI doesn’t have a business model yet and they don’t make any money so it makes sense that they haven’t shed the startup label. Like a roughly accurate test is to imagine what would happen if all the outside investments disappeared overnight. Could OpenAI continue operating on its own two feet? If the answer is no, it’s still a startup.
He said they “did not pull any punches” which implies it was a more blunt conversation than you’re suggesting.
Hank Green himself describes his relationship with AI the same way you would an addiction, and specifically mentions the dopamine reaction driving his use of it to a point where he became overwhelmed by it.
He’s not describing a casual discussion about table salt, he’s literally describing a drug/alcohol addiction.
His AI use caused him so many problems in his private life that his family had to intervene. His point of view is “This technology has had a negative impact on my life and the lives of the people I care about”.
The way ATproto works is all your data is stored in a database called a PDS, every post, reply etc. unlike Mastodon or Lemmy, this PDS isn't a part of an “instance” like Lemmy.world, and it doesn’t actually matter who hosts it. You could host the PDS yourself.
BlueSky is not an instance, it’s an “AppView” which is just a predefined set of rules/API, and it expects certain data in your PDS to look a certain way, and then to simplify a bit it just pulls the data out of your PDS and everyone else’s PDS all over the internet. The thing OP linked to is a Client that connects to the BlueSky AppView. But all the data still just lives in whatever PDS you store your data in. So if BlueSky disappeared tomorrow, you could write another AppView that just has to fit the same schema that the data in your PDS uses and it’d be like it never left.
To simplify further, if Mastodon and Lemmy work like Email, ATproto words like RSS. Your PDS is like your own hosted blog. Bluesky is like an RSS reader that just reads everyone’s PDS data. If the RSS reader vanishes, your data is still there, you just have to make a new RSS reader to read the data
Important note here, Eurosky and Bluesky aren’t two separate instances where your data is separate from Bluesky. When you use EuroSky, you’re just using BlueSky and it has all the same access to your data. The difference is just that your data is stored on EuroSky’s servers.
ATproto doesn’t have instances the way Mastodon or Lemmy do with Activitypub, and privacy is not really something it does.
The reason this is happening is because the cost of DRAM is ballooning the prices of all electronics and they are fully aware that people can’t pay the new higher prices even if they wanted to. Lower monthly payments is the difference between whether a lot of people buy an Apple or Samsung device at all.
I wouldn’t call this move nefarious on its own, but it is a dystopian side affect of the real problem which is DRAM price gauging.
In America you can have whatever the top tier of vision insurance is available to you and it’s basically a $100 off coupon for frames. I’ve never not spent $300-$400 for glasses.
An important thing to note here is that this isn’t anything new. This is what a significant amount of people have already been doing for years through their carrier. I don’t have any statistics on hand for this, but I personally don’t know a single person who has bought their phone outright. Everyone just leases their phone through their carrier around here, and upgrades as soon as they’re allowed. Hearing people complain about their cellphone plan cost increasing or poor cell service but being unable to switch carriers until their phone is paid off is a common thing to hear, as carriers have been using their phone leasing programs as a substitute for plan contracts for awhile now.
Leasing your phone through your carrier with the ability to buy or turn it in at the end of the term has been the name of the game for a very long time. What Apple and Samsung are doing is just trying to entice you into going direct through them instead of your carrier which is actually a good thing.
If you’ve been buying your phone outright then you shouldn’t use a program like this, but if you’ve been leasing your phone through your carrier I’d actually recommend switching to just doing the same thing directly through the manufacturer since it frees you up to switch carriers whenever you want.
Hmm I don’t remember mobbing anyone. All I did was reiterate what the man himself said, in the face of you trying to spin it as more pro than it was.
When the guy says his AI use was causing him problems and he regrets it and wants to make a change, I believe him. Simple as.
lol sure pal. At least stick to your guns next time.
You’ve said plenty pro-AI lol. You don’t have to get so defensive about it, just own your position.
I’ve exaggerated nothing. Hank himself said he’s spoken to both his wife and brother about his AI use and said they “didn’t pull any punches”, which implies there was a blunt conversation about it, if not two.
Startup doesn’t really have a strict definition but generally the term is used for a business with an unproven business model that has to scale rapidly just to be viable, and often relies on VC funding. This is opposed to like starting your own plumbing business with your own capital and you’re profitable as soon as you pick up a couple regular clients.
OpenAI doesn’t have a business model yet and they don’t make any money so it makes sense that they haven’t shed the startup label. Like a roughly accurate test is to imagine what would happen if all the outside investments disappeared overnight. Could OpenAI continue operating on its own two feet? If the answer is no, it’s still a startup.
That’s probably why he wrote an in depth explanation of what he did, his motive, how it affected him etc.
His public posts on the matter were not made for the people who actually know him.
The user is not in between, they’re pro AI.
That’s exactly how that works lmao. “Anti” means “opposite”, not some neutral third thing
Like what
He said they “did not pull any punches” which implies it was a more blunt conversation than you’re suggesting.
Hank Green himself describes his relationship with AI the same way you would an addiction, and specifically mentions the dopamine reaction driving his use of it to a point where he became overwhelmed by it.
He’s not describing a casual discussion about table salt, he’s literally describing a drug/alcohol addiction.
Being anti-anti something is being pro-something. That’s the beauty of the double negative.
Also that’s just a very pro-AI user, so the intent can be inferred
His AI use caused him so many problems in his private life that his family had to intervene. His point of view is “This technology has had a negative impact on my life and the lives of the people I care about”.
Your pro-AI spiel is a bit tone deaf here
Oh yeah it’s not just you, ATproto is very different from our usual way of thinking. Took me a bit to wrap my head around it at first too
The way ATproto works is all your data is stored in a database called a PDS, every post, reply etc. unlike Mastodon or Lemmy, this PDS isn't a part of an “instance” like Lemmy.world, and it doesn’t actually matter who hosts it. You could host the PDS yourself.
BlueSky is not an instance, it’s an “AppView” which is just a predefined set of rules/API, and it expects certain data in your PDS to look a certain way, and then to simplify a bit it just pulls the data out of your PDS and everyone else’s PDS all over the internet. The thing OP linked to is a Client that connects to the BlueSky AppView. But all the data still just lives in whatever PDS you store your data in. So if BlueSky disappeared tomorrow, you could write another AppView that just has to fit the same schema that the data in your PDS uses and it’d be like it never left.
To simplify further, if Mastodon and Lemmy work like Email, ATproto words like RSS. Your PDS is like your own hosted blog. Bluesky is like an RSS reader that just reads everyone’s PDS data. If the RSS reader vanishes, your data is still there, you just have to make a new RSS reader to read the data
What OP linked to is actually EuroSky’s new AppView, but you’re correct that none of this data is somehow separated from the BlueSky users.
EDIT: Oh Woops it’s actually not an AppView yet
Important note here, Eurosky and Bluesky aren’t two separate instances where your data is separate from Bluesky. When you use EuroSky, you’re just using BlueSky and it has all the same access to your data. The difference is just that your data is stored on EuroSky’s servers.
ATproto doesn’t have instances the way Mastodon or Lemmy do with Activitypub, and privacy is not really something it does.
The reason this is happening is because the cost of DRAM is ballooning the prices of all electronics and they are fully aware that people can’t pay the new higher prices even if they wanted to. Lower monthly payments is the difference between whether a lot of people buy an Apple or Samsung device at all.
I wouldn’t call this move nefarious on its own, but it is a dystopian side affect of the real problem which is DRAM price gauging.
In America you can have whatever the top tier of vision insurance is available to you and it’s basically a $100 off coupon for frames. I’ve never not spent $300-$400 for glasses.
An important thing to note here is that this isn’t anything new. This is what a significant amount of people have already been doing for years through their carrier. I don’t have any statistics on hand for this, but I personally don’t know a single person who has bought their phone outright. Everyone just leases their phone through their carrier around here, and upgrades as soon as they’re allowed. Hearing people complain about their cellphone plan cost increasing or poor cell service but being unable to switch carriers until their phone is paid off is a common thing to hear, as carriers have been using their phone leasing programs as a substitute for plan contracts for awhile now.
Leasing your phone through your carrier with the ability to buy or turn it in at the end of the term has been the name of the game for a very long time. What Apple and Samsung are doing is just trying to entice you into going direct through them instead of your carrier which is actually a good thing.
If you’ve been buying your phone outright then you shouldn’t use a program like this, but if you’ve been leasing your phone through your carrier I’d actually recommend switching to just doing the same thing directly through the manufacturer since it frees you up to switch carriers whenever you want.
If you asked me a few years ago I would have told you a PS5 easy as a big PlayStation fan.
But the way prices are these days, and Sony’s growing disdain for its users, and lack of competition from Xbox, you should 100% just get a PC.
“HugeNerd”
“Ok so that was a fucking lie”