Greens were deliberately setting up the vote to fail, due to procedural motions in the lower house always being opposed.
Whatever the fuck that's supposed to mean.
It failed 80 votes to 5. The 5 included the 4 Greens MPs and independent MP Andrew Wilkie. The fact that there were only 80 noes makes it hard to say precisely who they were and indicates that everyone was so sure it would fail by a large margin that Labor and the LNP didn't bother whipping up their MPs to go vote for it. Disappointing that the other independents didn't bother either.
Half the independents got in on a campaign that they would basically be Liberals except giving a shit about climate change, so we shouldn't really be surprised. Allegra Spender was out there the other day calling the uni encampments anti-semitic 🙄
Disagree. I understand what you're getting at, but I don't think it accurately represents what he said. If he had said "the Greens set this up to fail because Labor has no interest in supporting Palestinian statehood", he would have been right. But he didn't say it would fail because they don't support it, he said it would fail because "it's procedural".
If Labor had decided to amend it to be more clear in what it would accomplish (because it would not, of course, actually result in the nation of Australia recognising Palestine, just the House of Representatives, a mostly meaningless gesture), or if the Labor Foreign Minister had turned around and recognised it officially through their powers, he would have a point. Heck, I'll allow Labor to the end of the week for me to say "hey, actually, Labor did the right thing here". But as it stands right now? Labor has no defence. Anything they try to say is a transparent attempt to avoid saying "we don't support Palestinian statehood" while holding exactly that position.
Could be a "right idea; terrible execution" situation, but I imagine that'd would be met proactively. So likely more a "meh idea; thankfully bad execution" scenario. Certainly may be some truth to Greens doing it for political coverage or play too, but never intending to go further. Too much bullshit to see clearly.
Either way, I honestly don't think many Australian voters care—bread's $4 a loaf—so neither do the parties. A likely sad truth. I don't watch/read the mainstream household news, so no idea what's covered in it these days, but Gaza isn't raised much in social groups, let alone Ukraine.
Good to see we still have bipartisan support for European colonial genocide after all these years!
Really warms my heart knowing that despite all the division these days parasitic rich fucks can still bond over ignoring the rights of people to the land they live on.
I guess genocide is base of Palestiian politics, not Israel. Israel is just fighting a war now, and they did a lot to avoid it.
UN, just another example of "out of touch and destructive"
genocide is base of Palestiian politics, not Israel.
Israel has been a genocidal state for decades. They've just become more "mask off" recently thanks to the casus belli provided to them by an event which anyone could have told you was an inevitable result of Israeli policy. (Policy that literally included propping up Hamas specifically because they're more extreme than PA and thus were more likely to destabilise things, which Netanyahu had no interest in.)
UN, just another example of "out of touch and destructive"
Love how you just make up irrelevant bullshit because it's convenient to your genocidal mindset.
Note that I didn't say anything about what the UN thinks. I mentioned that the vast majority of countries in the world recognise Palestine. I just used UN membership as a proxy for what counts as a country. A convenient but imperfect definition (for example, Palestine and Taiwan).
any support for you claims? Israel done a lot trying to live in peace with Palestinian, and it is ends up with them intentionally killing civilian. What you can do about enemy whose sole position is "Kill all Jews" ? They at war now. Israel do not genocide Palestinian, it wedges a war. There are plenty of arabs and muslims living normal live in Israel. Only very some need to be cordoned in prison city, to stop some them from killing.
20 Comments
Zagorath@aussie.zone · 20 pts · 2y
Labor's excuse:
Whatever the fuck that's supposed to mean.
It failed 80 votes to 5. The 5 included the 4 Greens MPs and independent MP Andrew Wilkie. The fact that there were only 80 noes makes it hard to say precisely who they were and indicates that everyone was so sure it would fail by a large margin that Labor and the LNP didn't bother whipping up their MPs to go vote for it. Disappointing that the other independents didn't bother either.
zero_gravitas@aussie.zone · 11 pts · 2y
Half the independents got in on a campaign that they would basically be Liberals except giving a shit about climate change, so we shouldn't really be surprised. Allegra Spender was out there the other day calling the uni encampments anti-semitic 🙄
Ilandar@aussie.zone · 5 pts · 2y
Zagorath@aussie.zone · 4 pts · 2y
Disagree. I understand what you're getting at, but I don't think it accurately represents what he said. If he had said "the Greens set this up to fail because Labor has no interest in supporting Palestinian statehood", he would have been right. But he didn't say it would fail because they don't support it, he said it would fail because "it's procedural".
If Labor had decided to amend it to be more clear in what it would accomplish (because it would not, of course, actually result in the nation of Australia recognising Palestine, just the House of Representatives, a mostly meaningless gesture), or if the Labor Foreign Minister had turned around and recognised it officially through their powers, he would have a point. Heck, I'll allow Labor to the end of the week for me to say "hey, actually, Labor did the right thing here". But as it stands right now? Labor has no defence. Anything they try to say is a transparent attempt to avoid saying "we don't support Palestinian statehood" while holding exactly that position.
saltesc@lemmy.world · 1 pts · 2y
Could be a "right idea; terrible execution" situation, but I imagine that'd would be met proactively. So likely more a "meh idea; thankfully bad execution" scenario. Certainly may be some truth to Greens doing it for political coverage or play too, but never intending to go further. Too much bullshit to see clearly.
Either way, I honestly don't think many Australian voters care—bread's $4 a loaf—so neither do the parties. A likely sad truth. I don't watch/read the mainstream household news, so no idea what's covered in it these days, but Gaza isn't raised much in social groups, let alone Ukraine.
Deceptichum@sh.itjust.works · 20 pts · 2y
This reinforces my decision to never vote or support liblab again.
Greens are the only viable leftist party in the country.
hanrahan@slrpnk.net · 7 pts · 2y
That has pretty much been the case for decades. Labour haven't been *left" since Gough Whitlam was PM.
unionagainstdhmo@aussie.zone · 1 pts · 2y
ada@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 4 pts · 2y
Yep
threeduck@aussie.zone · 1 pts · 2y
This
naevaTheRat@lemmy.dbzer0.com · 8 pts · 2y
Good to see we still have bipartisan support for European colonial genocide after all these years!
Really warms my heart knowing that despite all the division these days parasitic rich fucks can still bond over ignoring the rights of people to the land they live on.
A1kmm@lemmy.amxl.com · 6 pts · 2y
You can see whether your local federal MP voted for this here: https://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Hansard/Hansard_Display?bid=chamber/hansardr/27640/&sid=0011 - note the Ayes are voting to allow the debate on the motion (the first step to recognition of Palestine), and the Noes are voting to shut it down and not even talk about it.
Zagorath@aussie.zone · 3 pts · 2y
Conveniently, I already knew how my MP voted, because I live in Ryan. But thanks for the link. I didn't realise Hansard would be updated that quickly.
zik@aussie.zone · 4 pts · 2y
At what point do Labor realise "Are we the baddies?"
AllNewTypeFace@leminal.space · 1 pts · 2y
Australia is a Judaeochristian settler state, and as such has solidarity with other such states at a foundational level.
TheHolm@aussie.zone · -16 pts · 2y
So Greens once again show how out of touch and destructive they are.
Zagorath@aussie.zone · 16 pts · 2y
TIL opposing genocide and getting in line with 146 out of 193 UN members is "out of touch and destructive".
TheHolm@aussie.zone · -14 pts · 2y
I guess genocide is base of Palestiian politics, not Israel. Israel is just fighting a war now, and they did a lot to avoid it.
UN, just another example of "out of touch and destructive"
Ilandar@aussie.zone · 8 pts · 2y
hanrahan@slrpnk.net · 7 pts · 2y
Imagine punching somone in the face for decades, they strike back and you bawl abiut them starting it.
It's like a domestic violence sufferer finally striking back after years of abuse.
Zagorath@aussie.zone · 7 pts · 2y
Israel has been a genocidal state for decades. They've just become more "mask off" recently thanks to the casus belli provided to them by an event which anyone could have told you was an inevitable result of Israeli policy. (Policy that literally included propping up Hamas specifically because they're more extreme than PA and thus were more likely to destabilise things, which Netanyahu had no interest in.)
Love how you just make up irrelevant bullshit because it's convenient to your genocidal mindset.
Note that I didn't say anything about what the UN thinks. I mentioned that the vast majority of countries in the world recognise Palestine. I just used UN membership as a proxy for what counts as a country. A convenient but imperfect definition (for example, Palestine and Taiwan).
TheHolm@aussie.zone · -6 pts · 2y
any support for you claims? Israel done a lot trying to live in peace with Palestinian, and it is ends up with them intentionally killing civilian. What you can do about enemy whose sole position is "Kill all Jews" ? They at war now. Israel do not genocide Palestinian, it wedges a war. There are plenty of arabs and muslims living normal live in Israel. Only very some need to be cordoned in prison city, to stop some them from killing.
unionagainstdhmo@aussie.zone · 6 pts · 2y
Ilandar@aussie.zone · 3 pts · 2y
unionagainstdhmo@aussie.zone · 2 pts · 2y