Open beta testing for Lemmy 1.0.0

Reading through the codebase to find where those dastardly .ml devs injected the Leftist Extremism.

LET'S GOOOO

So many exciting features!! Love to see Lemmy come so far

Kudos on the major release. O7

Very cool! Made a test account, might play around with it.

Tags look Nice: https://voyager.lemmy.ml/post/16768

Take my money mr magic man

Is there any plan for having polls?

Epico!

Can't wait for Summit to start rolling out support for v1.

The links at the top (communities, multi communities) go the same color as the background when you hover on them, which makes them unreadable. The Voyager thing next to them is unreadable as well. This is with the default theme, in dark mode.

Also: clicking next on a community loads the same posts, checking the devtools, no cursor/page param is sent in the api request for posts. Home feeds do paginate.

Very minor nitpick: the button here is flowing out of the container:

This is great news! Really looking forward to oauth users coming in

Not gonna lie I was compulsively checking the community for the beta lol. This is amazing news to wake up to!

Cursor pagination is a potential big QOL upgrade

congratulations on 1.0! woooooo! 🎉🎉🎉

When creating a comm, there are icon/banner inputs. They are ignored and must be set after the comm is created.

The links at the top (communities, multi communities) go the same color as the background when you hover on them, which makes them unreadable. The Voyager thing next to them is unreadable as well. This is with the default theme, in dark mode.

Also: clicking next on a community loads the same posts, checking the devtools, no cursor/page param is sent in the api request for posts. Home feeds do paginate.

Very minor nitpick: the button here is flowing out of the container:

Long user notes don’t wrap

Trying to post to an unlisted community shows a “Not found” error.

Unlisted communities show on the creator’s/mod’s profile.

Trying to visit an unlisted community as a non-creator/mod shows an error.

Not a regression, but not fixed: chat view doesn’t show comments below the fold.

When trying to edit this post the body never loads. E: Luckily, editing it without setting the body doesn’t clear it, and I can copy the source and edit to actually update, but that’s painful.

Also, I’ll figure out soon what happened previously, but: an mp4 I tried to render in the post looked like it would work well enough when previewing, but created a pictrs mirror that fails with:

{"error":"unknown","message":"error sending request for url (http://pictrs:8080/image/original?proxy=https%3A%2F%2Fscx2.b-cdn.net%2Fgfx%2Fvideo%2F2026%2Fbrookfield-zoo-chicago.mp4)","cause":"error sending request for url (http://pictrs:8080/image/original?proxy=https%3A%2F%2Fscx2.b-cdn.net%2Fgfx%2Fvideo%2F2026%2Fbrookfield-zoo-chicago.mp4)"}

I used to have reliable ways of escaping the create post / cross post screen through navigation (back button basically never works when there’s some content) but now I end up even more stuck than I used to be.

I tried the new signup via Github and got an error

client.js:2 Request error while calling POST /oauth/authenticate with {"code":"CODEREDACTED","oauth_provider_id":1,"redirect_uri":"https://voyager.lemmy.ml/oauth/callback"}
wrapper	@	client.js:2

I tried to export/import my user settings and subscriptions, but the import failed in voyager with a 400 error (I didn’t have the network tab open so I didn’t see the error message, and now I’m rated limited so I’ll have to wait to check again)

Previously, errors generally would leave the content you tried to post available to retry or copy. I am currently rate limited, and the rate limit error clears the contents of my comment. If I had typed a meaningful comment, it would have been lost.

The superscript icon doesn’t handle links (or the markdown library handles it incorrectly?).

This text:

Rhino horns are a prized commodity on the black market, and organized criminal networks are involved in smuggling them from Africa to Asia. Image by [Rollison, Nan](https://www.fws.gov/media/rhino-horns) (Public Domain).

Is converted to:

^Rhino\ horns\ are\ a\ prized\ commodity\ on\ the\ black\ market,\ and\ organized\ criminal\ networks\ are\ involved\ in\ smuggling\ them\ from\ Africa\ to\ Asia.\ Image\ by\ [Rollison,\ Nan](https://www.fws.gov/media/rhino-horns)\ (Public\ Domain).^

Which does not render the link properly:

^Rhino\ horns\ are\ a\ prized\ commodity\ on\ the\ black\ market,\ and\ organized\ criminal\ networks\ are\ involved\ in\ smuggling\ them\ from\ Africa\ to\ Asia.\ Image\ by\ Rollison,\ Nan\ (Public\ Domain).^

This markdown would render properly, maybe others would too:

^Rhino\ horns\ are\ a\ prized\ commodity\ on\ the\ black\ market,\ and\ organized\ criminal\ networks\ are\ involved\ in\ smuggling\ them\ from\ Africa\ to\ Asia.\ Image\ by^ [^Rollison,\ Nan^](https://www.fws.gov/media/rhino-horns) ^(Public\ Domain).^

^Rhino\ horns\ are\ a\ prized\ commodity\ on\ the\ black\ market,\ and\ organized\ criminal\ networks\ are\ involved\ in\ smuggling\ them\ from\ Africa\ to\ Asia.\ Image\ by^ ^Rollison,\ Nan^ ^(Public\ Domain).^

It also fails to handle multi-paragraph selections properly.

Feature request:

• set default notification behavior for my own posts
• set default notification behavior for posts I comment on

Very recent regression: pushing any of the styling buttons on the comment input automatically posts it immediately

Looks nice but definitely going to take some getting used to the new UI changes. Liking it for most part.

Not able to successfully post an image so far, maybe something broke with iterations going on. They never show a thumbnail after upload and disappear from the post.

Possibly related to the lack of local subscribers but my comment never* federated to Voyager and my edits never federated here.

*it’s been a few minutes which is usually enough

While federation between here and voyager clearly somewhat worked at one point, it seems like it’s currently broken. Before starting this test, I verified that Voyager has 1 local subscriber to this comm. I then upvoted a different comment from each instance, and commented on the one I upvoted from the other instance. Neither my votes or comments appear to have federated in either direction.

On https://phiresky.github.io/lemmy-federation-state/site?domain=lemmy.ml voyager’s last successful activity has increased several times.

On https://phiresky.github.io/lemmy-federation-state/site?domain=voyager.lemmy.ml I consistently get an error.

I upvoted this comment on ml and commented on it from voyager: https://voyager.lemmy.ml/post/16766/13025#comment-13025

I upvoted this comment on voyager and commented on it from ml: https://lemmy.ml/post/47547535/25761105

Unable to manage (revoke) Private comm membership post-subscribe (maybe via ban if the user posts? Can’t if no post, haven’t verified if ban actually revokes view access) E: permanent bans do revoke access, haven’t tested others. Bans don’t show in your public modlog, do show in user inbox. That maybe makes sense. Request to (re)subscribe button does nothing?

Unable to manage (grant) Private comm membership post-denial (unless user revokes and re-requests subscription)

Notification for pending membership request not visible in header, only when expanding menu.

Moderator Controls:

• can “distinguish as moderator” own comments, but not own posts
• can “feature in community” posts by other users, but not “feature” comments in threads
• no controls for posts or comments by Admins
  • maybe y’all don’t agree as admins, but I would expect all the same controls as for other users - feature/unfeature posts (and comments, ideally), lock/remove/warn, ban/unban/appoint or remove mod, view votes, edit as mod (given its limited options)

Perhaps with exceptions if an admin has used a “distinguish” feature themselves?

I can certainly see arguments for why mods shouldn’t be able to do some of these things - some suggest a level of disagreement that perhaps means the comm should find a new home (ban/remove/warn in particular) but the others don’t feel like they rise to the same level of disagreement, and I’d still argue that, for example, failing to post a frog (or at least a toad) should be moderatable activity.

Checking today, on Voyager:

• communities I’ve previously subscribed/created all say “subscribe pending”
• presumably related, https://voyager.lemmy.ml/c/LessSecretFrogStash displays a “Private” banner and says I don’t have access

On enterprise:

• my comment has not federated to voyager
• same “pending” issue subscribing to a voyager comm

Editing empty multicomms is unintuitive. After creation, the “Subscribe to some communities.” text links to the comm list, which has subscription buttons, but are not for subscribing the multi, but me. It’s probably just reusing the view when you’ve subscribed to nothing, but ideally would either:

• have “subscribe” linked to the multi settings
• link to a comm list that subscribes the multi instead of the user
• have some additional text like “from the multi-community settings”

Also, unintuitive to display for users who didn't create the empty multi

Dark themes all(?) have issues with white-on-white text in comm selector, RBlind themes are both horrific in their own unique ways:

I haven’t really looked in depth at any of the themes, I’ve mostly been using darkly-compact, though I couldn’t tell you what’s different from darkly.

Hello @nutomic, could you add my instance to the allowlist? I'd like to test federation with private communities.

Type: Posts

Does not filter out comments on user profile

On my profile page, I can no longer visit the post I commented on because the text from the card is behind the link but takes focus

Also, my avatar appears on comments, but not posts.