You have to invent a new type of candy or dessert, but if it's physically impossible or another commenter can prove it already exists, you lose. What are you making?

y'all're going about this all wrong, trying to come up with things that sound gross. the real strategy is to describe something you wish existed but doesn't. then if someone points out that it does, you "lose" by finding out about a food you would really like but were unaware of.

anyway, mine is coffee chocolate chip walnut ice cream (even though apparently op says new ice cream flavors don't count). so if anyone knows where I can buy coffee chocolate chip walnut ice cream, come own me so hard, I'll be devastated

Bitter Boys. Think Sour Patch kids, but instead of being coated in sour powder, it's extreme bitterness.

De-tangled cotton candy. Just a single razor thin thread of sugar like a mile long.

Nice try, Slugworth...

Honey butter aerogel with suspended almonds and pistachios in a dark chocolate cone.

Stir-fry flavoured ice cream.

I'm thinking a puff pastry roll filled with a minty sweet creamy filling and chocolate chips. That shit would be bomb, tell me it exists already so I can get some!

sulfur hexafluoride poprocks.

There's a good chance they'll still pop and sizzle a little bit, but the gas they release will cause your voice to lower.

I'm gonna shred some vegan chocolate and put it with tomato sauce on a lightly toasted flat dough, then stick it in the oven. Pizza with chocolate instead of cheese.

Phase-Order Candy Prism.

Picture a small edible prism made of ultra-thin layers of sugar glass and gelatinized starch, but the trick is in the internal structure of each layer contains flavor “micro-reservoirs” embedded in lipid membranes tuned to dissolve at different osmotic thresholds, not time.

Nice try, Wonka

Chocolate Epstein files

I'm thinking of something like an asthma inhaler, but you don't inhale and instead of medicine being ejected when activated a fine powder of concentrated flavor comes out. The powder flavors your saliva for a few seconds to a minute. And, since rumor has it that 50% of taste is smell, it a complimentary scent will also be exposed when activating.

Tasty flavor treat with minimal or possible even 0 calories.

Candy that smells like the house I grew up in specifically. Totally possible, but guaranteed not to exist. (Especially because there would almost certainly be no market for it, even including me)

This is based off a candy in a book, that I can't tell if has ever been made:

Under its tamarind glaze, luscious pepsin-flavored nougat, chock-full of tangy candied cubeb berries, and a chewy camphor-gum center.

Chocolate-coated tacks.

avocado flavor bubblegum

Existential horror topped with whipped cream.

Silk worm cotton candy. Infuse the silk with sugar and flavors. Roll it into a ball and shove a stick in it.

I could go for some mint chocolate syrup poured over vanilla ice cream. That would slap. Please make me lose.

Personal sized pie crust, with one scoop of vanilla ice cream. Take one tablespoon of low-sodium soy sauce, and mix in brown sugar until saturated. Drizzle the resulting syrup over the ice cream. Don't know what to call it, but I'd try it.

Never seen cinnamon pudding beforr but it wouldn't be very difficult to make

Something so blue it hurts to look at.

Whipped seafoam and cattail mousse.

Hard-candy lozenges flavored with my DNA.

I'm going to steal Strong Bad's idea here. https://homestarrunner.com/sbemails/149-candy-product

cum flavored taffy

I don't know other than to say that we need more savory candies for those of us who aren't into sweets. And crackers don't count.

Strawberrys frozen over with alternating thin layers of chocolate and mascarpone!

Healthy chocolate pudding!

Semla with rose jam filling

uhh, just like a vanilla cake. no way somebody else goes with that

chocolate covered jellybeans boiled in sugar and gumified

we're making cherry glazed fruit cake flavored from acetone.